According to the Bleader's Log (as it is affectionately called in the Executive Corridor), the initial discussion about the school, was not a discussion about the School in Eriskay but a discussion with the community about education provision in Eriskay, that may or may not included a discussion - and most definitely not a consultation - about the school in Eriskay.
Further clarification of the clarification makes it perfectly clear that the planned discussions weren't going to happen anyway. At least not in the terms that were previously de-announced.
That this contradicts the position taken by the Comhairle at it's last meeting, and reiterated in private at the COSLA Meeting, and explained to Members as the outcome of the COSLA decision is neither here nor there. I saw some of the detail last week from the unusual sources.
As the Bleader puts it:
Parents deserve to have the correct information.Perhaps an FOI to see the internal emails and discussion might help the parents have the correct information.
Make no mistake, education provision in the islands needs reform - that's code for rationalisation, or closures - unless the birth rate picks up dramatically, but the least the Council can do is be honest about it and point out that the absence of kids is not conducive to the continued existence of a school.
The moratorium might not be right, or fair, or economically advantageous, as far as the Council is concerned, but the Government wield the big big, big stick and sometimes a different approach is required.
(Declaration of interest: I first went to Eriskay about 1975, and I loved the place. Even just driving through it is blissful.)